on the teaching
Too much that is known about how to teach spelling isn't
being put into practice. I can think of no subject we teach more poorly
or harbor more myths about than spelling.Richard Gentry, 1987
For decades, more people seem to have considered themselves poor spellers
than good spellers, despite the fact that most of us spell correctly the
vast majority of the words we write. With spelling, we seem to expect that
all of us should spell one hundred percent correctly, even on first drafts,
and even as young children. Perhaps it is this unrealistic expectation
that leads some parents and others to object when teachers use newer methods
of helping children learn to spell, such as encouraging children to "use
invented spelling" in their early attempts to write. Such critics
mistakenly assume that children who initially use approximate spellings
will never become good spellers, or that if the time-honored method of
memorizing spelling lists were used instead, every child would become a
perfect speller. Neither observed experience nor research supports these
What research demonstrates
- Young children using invented spelling employ a considerably greater
variety of words in their writing than those encouraged to use only the
words they can spell correctly (Gunderson & Shapiro, 1987, 1988; Clarke,
1988; Stice & Bertrand, 1990).
- By the end of first grade, children encouraged to use invented spellings
typically score as well or better on standardized tests of spelling than
children allowed to use only correct spellings in first drafts (Clarke,
1988; Stice & Bertrand, 1990).
- Young children encouraged to use invented spellings seem to develop
word recognition and phonics skills sooner than those not encouraged to
spell the sounds they hear in words (Clarke, 1988).
- At least in grades 3-6, it is not clear that spelling instruction has
much of an effect beyond what is learned through reading alone, if children
are reading extensively (Krashen, 1991).
What helps children learn to spell
- Learners of all ages need encouragement to write, write, write, and
just to spell words the best they can in first drafts.
- As young children begin to hear separate sounds in words, they benefit
from help in writing the sounds they hear: that is, from guidance in inventing
spellings. Gradually, their initial invented spellings (usually one letter
per word) more or less naturally give way to more complete and sophisticated
invented spellings and to conventional spellings, as long as the children
are reading and writing extensively.
- Extensive exposure to print helps children internalize not only the
spellings of particular words, but spelling patterns. Young children especially
benefit from reading favorite selections again and again. Learners of all
ages need to read, read, read.
- Children benefit from guidance in developing a spelling conscience:
a concern for spelling, and a sense of when something may not be spelled
correctly. For instance, as a first step toward correcting their spelling,
children who are already spelling many words correctly might be encouraged
to circle words in their first draft that they think might be spelled incorrectly.
- Teaching children strategies for correcting spelling is far more important
than giving them the correct spelling of any particular word. Such strategies
include: writing the word two or three different ways and deciding which
one "looks right"; locating the correct spelling in a familiar
text or in print displayed in the classroom; asking someone, consulting
a dictionary, or using a spelling checker on the computer or a hand-held
- Spelling strategies and major spelling patterns can be taught much
more effectively through minilessons involving student discussion than
through workbook pages or spelling tests. Children benefit especially when,
as a group, they are guided in noticing spelling patterns for themselves.
- By the intermediate grades and middle school, students can benefit
immensely from minilessons that help them discover the meanings of Latin
and Greek roots and suffixes. Such learning is valuable for spelling and
writing but perhaps even more valuable for vocabulary development and reading.
- Studying spelling lists is most useful if children each choose a limited
number of words (say five a week) that they want to learn: ideally, words
they are interested in, and words they use frequently in their writing
but haven't yet learned to spell correctly all the time. At the end of
the week, partners can test each other on the words they each have practiced
during the week.
- Individualized spelling dictionaries can be helpful as children are
trying to get a grasp on the spellings of words. Teachers can make each
child a booklet in which the child can enter words he or she is learning
to spell. File boxes with index cards, or even computer files or data bases
for each child, can serve the same purpose.
REFERENCES AND RESOURCES
Bolton, F., & Snowball, D. (1993). Teaching
spelling: A practical resource. Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann.
Buchanan, E. (1989). Spelling for whole language classrooms.
Katonah, NY: Richard C. Owen.
Clarke, L. K. (1988). Invented versus traditional spelling
in first graders' writings: Effects on learning to spell and read. Research
in the Teaching of English, 22, 281-309.
Cunningham, P. M. (1995). Phonics they use: Words for
reading and writing (2nd ed.). New York: HarperCollins College Pubs.
Gentry, J. Richard. (1987). Spel
. . . is a four-letter word. Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann.
Gunderson, L., & Shapiro, J. (1987). Some findings
on whole language instruction. Reading-Canada-Lecture, 5
Gunderson, L., & Shapiro, J. (1988). Whole language
instruction: Writing in 1st grade. The Reading Teacher, 41,
Laminack, L. L., & Wood, K. (1996). Spelling in
use. Urbana, IL: National Council of Teachers of English.
McGee, L. M., & Richgels, D. J. (1990). Literacy's
beginnings: Supporting young readers and writers. Boston: Allyn and
Routman, R. (1991). Invitations:
Changing as teachers and learners K-12. Portsmouth, NH:
Routman, R., & Maxim, D. (1996). Invented spelling:
What it is and what it isn't. School Talk, 1 (4). Urbana,
IL:National Council of Teachers of English.
Stice, C. F., & Bertrand, N. P. (1990). Whole language
and the emergent literacy of at-risk children: A two-year comparative study.
Nashville: Center for Excellence, Basic Skills, Tennessee State University.
ERIC: ED 324 636.
Temple, C., Nathan, R., Temple, F., & Burris, N. A.
(1993). The beginnings of writing (3rd ed.). Boston: Allyn and Bacon.
Wilde, S. (1992). You kan red
this! Spelling and punctuation for whole language classrooms, K-6.
Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann.
Prepared for the Michigan English Language Arts Framework project and
© 1996 by Constance
Weaver. A similar version was published as a SLATE Starter Sheet by
the National Couincil of Teachers of English (1996). In C. Weaver, L. Gillmeister-Krause,
& G. Vento-Zogby, Creating Support for Effective
Literacy Education (Heinemann, 1996).
May be copied.
Previous sheet | Next
sheet | Fact